Hiring Through the End of 2026: How to Win the Best Talent in a More Selective Market

Jen Caison • August 26, 2026

If you're planning to hire between now and the end of the year, there is something important to understand about today's labor market:


More available candidates does not necessarily mean more available talent.


The U.S. entered September with approximately 7.3 million open jobs. Hiring has slowed, employees are changing jobs less frequently, and companies are generally being more selective about adding headcount.


On the surface, that might sound like great news for employers. Post a job, collect a large applicant pool and take your time choosing the best person.

Unfortunately, that's not necessarily how this market is working.


The strongest candidates, particularly experienced professionals with specialized skills, are often still employed. They aren't spending their evenings applying to dozens of postings. And because changing jobs feels riskier in an uncertain market, they need a compelling reason to leave a position where they're already successful.


That changes how companies need to recruit.


Don't Confuse Applicant Volume with Candidate Quality


One of the biggest hiring challenges of 2026 is the sheer volume of applications employers can receive. Technology has made applying easier than ever, and AI has made it possible for candidates to create and submit applications at extraordinary speed.

The result?


A company may receive hundreds of résumés and still struggle to find the person it actually needs. In fact, recent employer research found that 58% of business leaders say finding skilled professionals is more difficult than it was a year ago.


That's an important distinction.


The challenge isn't always finding people who want a job. It's finding the right person for your job.


Know What You Actually Need Before You Start Recruiting


Some of the most difficult searches begin with a job description that doesn't accurately reflect the problem the company needs the new hire to solve.


Before launching a search, get alignment around a few fundamental questions:


  • What does this person need to accomplish during their first year?
  • Which skills are truly required on day one?
  • Which qualifications would simply be nice to have?
  • What would make a successful person leave their current position to join us?


The clearer those answers are, the easier it becomes to identify the right candidate. This is particularly important for specialized positions. Industry experience, systems knowledge, leadership exposure or a particular technical background can dramatically reduce the actual candidate pool.


Know your non-negotiables but don't create so many of them that you eliminate excellent people who could successfully do the job.


Your Best Candidate May Not Be Looking for You


This is where recruiting in a selective market gets interesting. The person you ultimately hire may never apply to your job posting. They may be doing very well at another company.


A strong Controller isn't necessarily searching job boards every morning. Neither is a successful manufacturing leader, HR executive or experienced accounting professional. These candidates need to be identified, approached and given a reason to listen.


That's the difference between recruiting and simply collecting applications. When KCG conducts a search, we're not only asking, "Who is looking for a job?"


We're asking: "Who would be excellent at this job — and what would make that person consider moving?"


Those are two very different questions.


Give Great Candidates a Reason to Leave a Good Job


Compensation matters. Of course it does. But experienced passive candidates rarely make career decisions based on salary alone. They're evaluating the entire opportunity.


  • Will I have more responsibility?
  • Will I learn something?
  • Will I have access to stronger leadership?
  • Is the company growing?
  • Can I build something?
  • Will this position improve my trajectory three or five years from now?
  • What will my quality of life look like?
  • And perhaps most importantly: Why should I leave what I already have?


Companies that can clearly answer that question have a significant recruiting advantage. Your employer value proposition doesn't need to be flashy. It needs to be real.


Don't Let a Thorough Process Become a Slow Process


Being selective is smart. Dragging a strong candidate through six weeks of interviews because nobody owns the decision is not. One of the most preventable ways companies lose excellent candidates is unnecessary delay.


Decide who needs to interview the candidate. Determine what each person is evaluating. Establish the compensation range before interviewing begins. Get feedback quickly. And when you've identified someone exceptional, move.


A strong hiring process can be rigorous without being cumbersome. Candidates notice the difference. Your interview process is also one of their first experiences with how your company operates.


Remember That You're Interviewing Each Other


This becomes especially important when recruiting passive candidates. You may have approached them. They weren't necessarily planning to leave.

That means the interview can't operate exclusively as an evaluation of the candidate.


Of course you should ask difficult questions and thoroughly assess their capabilities. But you should also be prepared to explain why your company, leadership team and opportunity deserve serious consideration.


Great candidates have questions. Welcome them. The goal isn't simply to get someone to accept your offer. It's to create enough transparency on both sides that you're confident they'll still be happy they accepted it a year from now.


The Opportunity for Employers Through Year-End


The remainder of 2026 should continue to favor employers who hire deliberately — but not complacently. There are more candidates in the market than during the extreme talent shortages of several years ago. At the same time, highly specialized professionals remain difficult to recruit, particularly when they're already successfully employed.


So don't hire simply because someone is available.


  • Define what your business needs.
  • Know the market.
  • Find the people capable of delivering it.
  • Give them a compelling reason to consider you.


And when you find the right one, be prepared to move.


KCG Search helps companies identify and recruit exceptional talent across Accounting & Finance, Operations, Manufacturing, Human Resources and Administrative functions. We don't believe successful recruiting is about sending the most résumés. It's about finding the right person for the right opportunity.

Man looking at a gray wall with three white question marks
By Jen Caison September 2, 2026
Should you change jobs in 2026? Learn when to make a career move, what to consider before leaving and how to evaluate your next opportunity.
Human job candidate and robot waiting for an interview, representing AI's growing role in the hiring
By Debra Miller August 19, 2026
AI is changing the hiring process. Learn how employers can evaluate candidates, improve interviews and identify qualified talent beyond the resume.
Executive leadership boardroom with city skyline.
By Debra Miller March 5, 2026
Retention challenges begin long before employees leave. KCG’s Retention Strategy Framework identifies early misalignment to stabilize workforce continuity.
Quiet Cracking
By Debra Miller March 4, 2026
Discover how Quiet Cracking impacts engagement, retention, and culture—and learn proactive steps employers can take to reengage and retain top talent.
Reskilled, Upskilled, or Relaced
By Debra Miller March 3, 2026
Learn how to balance reskilling, upskilling, and strategic hiring to build a future-ready workforce equipped for AI, automation, and digital transformation.
Building trust
By Debra Miller March 2, 2026
Discover how authentic leadership, visibility, and connection build trust, strengthen culture, and shape the modern workplace in 2025 and beyond.
Talent Intelligence 2026
By Debra Miller March 2, 2026
Discover how finance leaders use talent intelligence and predictive recruitment metrics to anticipate hiring needs and build data-driven teams in 2026.
By Jen Caison March 1, 2026
Finance leadership has expanded far beyond traditional financial stewardship. CFOs and finance teams are no longer responsible only for reporting results or maintaining financial discipline. Increasingly, they are expected to help leadership teams interpret data, evaluate risk, and guide decisions that shape the business's direction. As organizations grow more complex and data-driven, finance occupies a unique position within many companies. It sits at the intersection of operations, strategy, and capital allocation. In many organizations, finance has become the function that translates information from across the business into insight that leadership teams can act on. Research reflects this shift. According to the Deloitte CFO Signals Survey, more than 60% of CFOs report being directly involved in shaping corporate strategy , demonstrating how finance leadership has moved beyond reporting responsibilities into broader organizational decision-making. Across industries, several priorities consistently define the finance agenda for leadership teams. AI and Automation Are Reshaping Finance Operations Artificial intelligence and automation are transforming how finance organizations operate. What began as automation of routine tasks is evolving into systems that help finance teams generate insight and support decision-making across the organization. Automation is reducing the time spent on activities such as reconciliations, reporting preparation, and data aggregation. As routine work becomes increasingly automated, finance leaders can focus more attention on analysis, forecasting, and strategic guidance. The challenge for finance leaders is not simply adopting new technology, but determining where automation creates meaningful value and ensuring teams have the capabilities to use these tools effectively. The CFO Role Continues to Expand Strategically The CFO's role extends well beyond financial oversight. Finance leaders frequently play a central role in conversations that shape organizational strategy, investment decisions, and operational priorities. Because finance sits close to the flow of financial and operational data, CFOs often serve as interpreters of performance signals for leadership teams. Their ability to translate financial information into business insight allows executives to make more informed decisions about how the organization allocates resources and pursues growth. In many organizations, CFOs are helping guide decisions that affect: Long-term growth planning Capital allocation and investment prioritization Operational strategy and performance improvement Enterprise risk management Finance Transformation Is Accelerating Many organizations are investing heavily in finance transformation initiatives designed to improve visibility into financial performance and strengthen the connection between financial data and operational decision-making. Modern finance functions increasingly rely on integrated systems that provide faster access to information and deeper insight into how the organization is performing across functions. Organizations are investing in capabilities such as: Cloud-based ERP platforms Automated reporting systems Integrated financial planning tools Real-time analytics dashboards These systems allow finance teams to move beyond static reports and develop clearer insight into how financial performance connects to operational outcomes. Finance Talent Is Becoming a Strategic Constraint As finance organizations evolve, the capabilities required within finance teams are changing as well. CFOs increasingly need professionals who combine strong accounting foundations with analytical, technological, and strategic skills. Deloitte indicates that 60% of finance leaders say hiring professionals with AI and data capabilities has become a major priority for finance organizations . Organizations increasingly seek finance professionals who bring a combination of technical expertise and business understanding, including: Strong accounting and financial fundamentals Systems and technology proficiency Analytical problem-solving capability The ability to collaborate effectively with business leaders As finance organizations continue to evolve, building the right team becomes just as important as implementing the right systems. Financial Discipline Remains Essential Even as organizations invest in new technologies and pursue operational transformation, financial discipline remains a central responsibility for finance leadership. CFOs must continually evaluate where resources are being allocated while ensuring the organization maintains financial stability and operational efficiency. Effective finance leaders are often balancing two priorities simultaneously: Supporting innovation and growth Protecting the organization against financial risk Maintaining that balance requires thoughtful capital allocation, careful investment evaluation, and clear visibility into how resources are deployed across the organization. A Strategic Perspective on Finance Leadership Technology, systems, and transformation initiatives are reshaping the finance function. The success of those initiatives ultimately depends on the people leading them. Finance leaders combine technical expertise with the ability to interpret complex information and translate it into guidance that leadership teams can act on. In many organizations, finance is uniquely positioned to connect signals across the business and help leaders understand how operational decisions influence financial performance. How KCG Search Supports Finance Leadership Strategy Finance leadership is expanding as organizations rely more heavily on financial insight to guide strategic decisions. As finance teams take on greater responsibility for connecting operational performance with financial outcomes, the expectations placed on finance leaders continue to grow. Organizations increasingly need finance professionals who combine strong technical expertise with the ability to interpret complex information, collaborate with executive teams, and translate financial data into actionable insight. At KCG Search, we partner with CFOs and executive leadership teams to identify finance professionals who bring both analytical depth and strategic perspective to their organizations. Our work focuses on helping leadership teams build finance capabilities that strengthen decision clarity, operational visibility, and long-term business performance. If you are building a finance team aligned with your organization's strategic priorities, we would welcome the opportunity to continue that conversation. 
Strategic CFO interpreting financial and operational signals across an interconnected business netwo
By Debra Miller March 1, 2026
The CFO role is rapidly evolving. Learn how strategic CFOs are becoming the decision engine of modern organizations and why finance leadership is critical for businesses
White question marks of increasing size, arranged in a row against a light background.
By Debra Miller February 18, 2026
The most reliable predictor of a potential employee's future performance is based on their past performance. That is the foundation of competency-based interviewing. Competencies go beyond a list of skills or credentials. They reflect how a candidate applies their knowledge and experience in real-world situations . It allows the potential candidate to demonstrate their thought process of navigating competing priorities, adapting to shifting expectations, and delivering results when the path forward requires judgment, not just protocols. When key stakeholders define and align on the required role responsibilities and expectations prior to candidate interviews, the outcome is invaluable: a consistent, equitable standard for evaluating every candidate against the role's actual demands. Understanding the 3 Question Types That Drive Better Interviews To truly assess a candidate’s fit, strong interviews blend behavioral, situational , and technical questions. Each type uncovers a different layer of ability and motivation. 1. Behavioral Questions – “How Have You Acted Before?” Purpose: Reveal how candidates have responded to real-world challenges. Why it matters: Past behavior often predicts future performance. Example: “Tell me about a time you had to manage conflicting priorities under pressure.” Look for ownership, reflection, and measurable results. 2. Situational Questions – “How Would You Act?” Purpose: Test how a candidate would approach a hypothetical challenge. Why it matters: Helps you assess decision-making, ethics, and alignment with company culture. Example: “If a key project started falling behind, how would you bring it back on track?” Strong candidates show calm analysis and proactive solutions. 3. Technical Questions – “Can You Do the Work?” Purpose: Confirm the candidate’s functional expertise and readiness for the role. Why it matters: Every great hire needs both judgment and technical fluency. Example: “Walk me through how you’d perform a month-end close across multiple entities.” These questions validate skill depth and adaptability to evolving tools and systems. 10 Competency Questions to Ask in 2026 1. Tell me about a time you had to make a decision with incomplete information. Provides hiring managers with an opportunity to evaluate a candidate’s critical thinking and composure under uncertainty. This question helps identify individuals who can balance risk and logic — a vital competency in fast-changing markets where perfect information rarely exists. 2. Describe a project where you collaborated across departments or regions. Reveals how well a candidate communicates and adapts in cross-functional environments. Strong answers demonstrate collaboration, empathy, and an understanding of organizational dynamics across diverse teams. 3. Give an example of how you used data to influence a business decision. Helps assess analytical ability and business acumen. This question spotlights candidates who can translate data into actionable insights that drive measurable outcomes. 4. Tell me about a time you identified an opportunity for improvement and took initiative. Uncovers ownership, curiosity, and accountability. It highlights candidates who proactively identify challenges and implement solutions — rather than waiting for direction. 5. Describe a situation where you had to adapt quickly to change. Evaluates resilience, flexibility, and composure under shifting priorities. Look for candidates who stay solution-oriented and maintain performance amid uncertainty or disruption. 6. Share how you built trust within a team or with a client. Explores emotional intelligence and communication style. Candidates who can describe specific trust-building actions often bring stronger relationships, collaboration, and influence. 7. Tell me about a goal you didn’t meet — and what you learned from it. Assesses humility, self-awareness, and a growth mindset. The most valuable responses show reflection, accountability, and how lessons learned improved later performance. 8. Explain how you manage competing priorities and deadlines. Tests time management, decision-making, and strategic focus. This question highlights how candidates assess urgency versus impact to maintain consistent, high-quality outcomes. 9. Describe how you’ve contributed to a more inclusive or collaborative culture. Explores leadership, empathy, and team engagement. Strong responses show intentional efforts to support inclusion, belonging, and stronger collective performance. 10. Tell me about a time you influenced others without direct authority. Assesses leadership potential and the ability to persuade through credibility and collaboration. Candidates who thrive in matrixed or cross-functional settings often excel in influencing outcomes through trust and communication. How to Make These Questions Work for You Tailor them to the role and seniority level. Listen for action verbs like led , improved , developed, and resolved . Ask follow-ups such as “What was the result?” or “What would you do differently?” These techniques help uncover the real story behind the résumé — the difference between a good interview and a great hire. Final Thought In 2026, the ideal interview looks beyond a potential candidate's experience to uncover behavior, mindset, and motivation. Competency-based questions help leaders identify and hire high-performing talent that can adapt, collaborate, and deliver results within a constantly changing environment. At KCG Search, we partner with finance, accounting, and marketing leaders to build interview strategies that go beyond credentials and uncover the competencies that actually predict long-term performance. If you would like to discuss how we can support you with your next search, we would welcome that conversation. Reach out to KCG Search today.
Show More